Hunting Bullet Metrics
Apply Terminal Performance Truth
Guppy-Metric Values Obtained from Gel Testing Various Expanding Hunting Bullets Shot from a 375 H&H Magnum, 300 Winchester Magnum, 358 Winchester, and 308 Winchester.
By Scott Fletcher
“A Mind is like a parachute. It doesn’t work if it is not open.” - Frank Zappa
This article presents Guppy-metric values of expanding hunting bullets obtained from all personal testing in 20% synthetic gel performed prior to 2023. These values are catalogued on Table 1 found here. This article also presents brief descriptions of the testing setup, the custom modifications made to selected bullets, and an example problem with guidance on how to interpret and apply the test results.
Be Advised: No bullet energy, mushroom diameter, weight loss, or sectional density values are presented. Terminal performance articles found on this website repeatedly demonstrate that these metrics do not reasonably predict field terminal performance reality, as indicated by field and skinning-shed data obtained on the 2023 zebra management hunt. At best, field predictions or interpretations using the referenced metrics are misleading; at worst, they are just plain wrong.
The Guppy-metric values for the cartridge-bullet combinations shown on Table 1 were obtained in 6-inch square (15.2 cm) by 16-inch long (40.6 cm) 20% synthetic gel blocks cast from the same lot. The test distance of 135 yards (123 m) is the average shot distance for all game taken in the Limpopo province of South Africa on five, 10-day hunts. An impala hide about 0.05 inches (1.3 mm) thick was draped over the front face of the initial gel block. No bone or material simulating bone was embedded in the gel. General testing photos are presented in the Bullet Testing Album, and the general testing procedures are described in eBook Chapter 12.
The testing included a .358-caliber, 225-grain Barnes TSX, fired from a 358 Winchester (358 Win). As shown on Photo 1, this bullet did not properly expand at a test impact velocity of 2219 feet per second (676 mps). Metric values for this cartridge-bullet combination are not included on Table 1 because the bullet essentially failed to perform satisfactorily at a hunt-average shot distance modeled by the test.
The failure of the stock 225 Barnes TSX to properly expand prompted a modification to its tip configuration. Two poly tips, each with a different shank diameter, were hand-installed on faced (milled) stock TSX bullets and subsequentially tested. Photo 2 shows the “small” tip on the left of a faced 225 TSX and a “large” tip on the right. The 225 TSX modified with the small tip is identified as the 358 Win-225 BST on Table 1; the 225 TSX modified with the large tip is identified as the 358 Win-225 BLT. A technical narrative of the rationale and conceptually-predicted outcomes for these modifications is presented on pages 4 through 7 in the article found here.
A typical match bullet is not considered satisfactory as a hunting bullet because its small-diameter meplat (tip) can produce erratic to no expansion during its penetration through an animal. To obtain reliable and consistent tip expansion/mushroom formation upon impact, a 30-caliber, 240-grain Sierra Match King was modified by hand-installing a poly tip on a faced bullet as shown in Photo 3. A technical narrative of the rationale for this modification is presented in Terminal Performance Time Out #4 on page 23 of the 2023 management hunt report.
Field and skinning-shed data obtained on the management hunt indicate Guppy-metric values of V(ST), L(T), and I(V), as identified by the Guppy model and defined in Guppy Tech, are reasonable empirical predictors of field wound volume, effective penetration length, and meat damage, respectively, when testing is performed in 20% synthetic gel at a distance that represents a typical hunt shot distance. These metric values are in bold print on Table 1. The six-part terminal performance article found here presents the physiological wound basis for the Guppy model, and describes the empirical relationships between the management-hunt data and the test- metric values of V(ST), L(T), and I(V).
The test values of V(ST), L(T), and I(V) only depend on an expanding hunting bullet’s generic design and impact velocity, not its diameter (caliber), sectional density, impact energy, mushroom diameter, and weight loss. If all testing is performed at the same test distance, these metric values, obtained in 20% synthetic gel, allow any cartridge-bullet combination to be numerically evaluated to identify which combination of test-metric values will likely produce the total field performance that meets each hunter’s specific hunt objectives. The following example using Guppy-metrics from Table 1 illustrates how these test values can be comparatively evaluated to obtain a strategic cartridge-bullet selection.
A hunter wants to trophy-hunt plains game in Africa. His outfitter has indicated typical shots will be less than 200 yards (182 m), and the maximum game weight expected is 750 pounds (341 kg). The hunter owns multiple hunting rifles, including one chambered in 358 Winchester (358 Win) and one chambered in 300 Winchester magnum (300 Win). The hunter hand loads, and can reproduce the ammunition with the ballistics implied on Table 1. As an option, the outfitter has indicated a 308 Winchester (308 Win) can be rented and will be furnished with ammunition loaded with a 165-grain Barnes TSX (BTSX).
The hunter assessed the test distance of 135 yards will be representative of an average shot distance on his hunt, and could rely on the Guppy-metric values catalogued on Table 1 for his field-performance evaluations. He is a student of his craft, and is familiar with all the terminal performance articles on this website.
The hunter pre-qualified all the cartridge-bullet combinations in .358 and .308 caliber catalogued on Table 1 for compliance with the caveat notes on page 5 of the article found here. He determined only the 300 Win-180 Swift A-Frame (SAF) and the 308 Win-165 BTSX were not in compliance with these notes. The estimated game weight (EGW) requirement of Note 2, calculated with impact velocities obtained using online ballistic software, was considerably less than 750 pounds at 200 yards for both cartridge-bullet combinations.
From his pre-qualification evaluations, the hunter deduced that the 358 Win used for testing the 225 Sierra Game King (SGK) was a ballistic twin of a 350 Rigby magnum (350 Rigby mag). The 358 Win had produced a muzzle velocity of 2625 fps with a 225-grain cup-and-core bullet, comparable to Rigby’s stated muzzle velocity of 2600 fps for a 35-caliber, 225-grain cup-and-core spitzer from this chambering. In his book African Rifles and Cartridges, John Taylor made the following statement about the 350 Rigby magnum: “I can strongly recommend this rifle for African use. It is one of the best of the ‘mediums’.”
The trophy fee would be charged for an unrecovered animal, and the hunter decided the hunt’s terminal performance priority was a cartridge-bullet combination that would likely produce the shortest travel distance after the shot to increase the odds of recovery. He had determined the plains-game animals on his bag list were non-dangerous, and decided the required penetration would only need to be “enough” to breach the animals’ rib cages from a high-percentage broadside shot. Finally, the hunter concluded meat preservation would not be a consideration on a trophy hunt. Based strictly on the hunter’s reasoning, the stated terminal performance objectives, and the data presented on Table 1, what would be reasonable cartridge-bullet choices?
The hunter’s foremost terminal performance priority is a recovered animal. He relied on Graph 1 from the 2023 management hunt that demonstrated travel distance after the kill shot linearly decreased with an increase in wound volume, as indicated by V(ST). He reviewed V(ST) values on Table 1 and determined the highest V(ST) value for either a .358-caliber or .308-caliber cartridge-bullet combination was 23.5 cubic inches (385 cm 3 ). This value was obtained for both a 250-grain Speer Hot-Cor (250 SPH) fired from a 358 Win, and a 200-grain Woodleigh Weldcore protected point (200 WWC) fired from a 300 Win. Since testing was performed at the same distance, he relied on both V(ST) magnitudes even though the results had been obtained from two different chamberings using bullets with different generic designs, calibers, weights, and sectional densities.
Meat damage was not a terminal performance consideration, and comparison of I(V) test values was not necessary. The only other terminal performance consideration was whether the L(T) test-penetration length values for either the 358 Win-250 SPH or the 300 Win-200 WWC would be “enough” to take the plains game under consideration.
The hunter could have used internet AI to determine representative rib-cage widths of the animals under consideration for the hunt, then compared those widths to the L(T) test-penetration lengths of the 358 Win-250 SPH and the 300 Win-200 WWC. Instead, the hunter relied on his deduction that the 358 Win-225 SGK was the ballistic twin of the 350 Rigby mag-225 cup-and-core spitzer because of their bullet’s common weight, cup-and-core generic design, and likely comparable impact velocities. Because of this commonality, he reasoned the 225 SGK launched by the 358 Win had produced test results comparable to what a 225-grain spitzer launched from a 350 Rigby mag would likely have produced at 135 yards. He concluded the 358 Win-225 SGK’s L(T) test-penetration length of 19-1/2 inches (50 cm) would likely be comparable to the 350 Rigby mag, and considered this penetration length to be “enough” based on the 350 Rigby magnum’s stellar and proven Africa-performance record.
The hunter noted the 358 Win-250 SPH’s L(T) test-penetration length of 32-inches (81 cm) and the 300 Win-200 WWC’s L(T) test-penetration length of 23-inches (58 cm) exceeded the 358 Win-225 SGK’s test-penetration length by considerable margins, indicating there was likely low risk of either bullet failing to completely breach any animal’s rib cage from a broadside shot. Based on these considerations and test data, the hunter concluded a 250 SPH, fired from his 358 Win, or a 200 WWC, fired from his 300 Win, would be more than satisfactory for the planned trophy hunt.
The hunter reviewed his analysis and decided his potential cartridge-bullet choices were reasonable and prudent. Nevertheless, he decided a “real-world” reality check was warranted due to the empirical evaluation factors of the analysis and the total cost of his planned hunt.
During the pre-qualification of the cartridge-bullet combinations identified on Table 1, the hunter had been surprised the 300 Win-180 SAF was deficient in its estimated game weight (EGW) at 200 yards. This cartridge-bullet combination had established an excellent field-performance reputation for hunting African plains game, including animals weighing 750 pounds.
Based on his knowledge of this website’s content, the hunter (correctly) concluded the equation used in Note 2 for pre-qualifying cartridge-bullet combinations was simply an empirical “place to start” for initially selecting bullets for gel testing or for field use if gel testing would not be performed. Since gel test results were available, the hunter focused on the 300 Win-180 SAF’s V(ST) value of 17.5, noting that it was comparable to the 358 Win-225 SGK’s value of 17.2. Since the 358 Win-225 SGK was the ballistic twin of the 350 Rigby mag-225 cup-and-core spitzer, he concluded the field wound volume produced at 135 yards by the 300 Win-180 SAF would likely be comparable to what a 350 Rigby mag would have produced. In that context, the 300 Win-180 SAF’s field-wounding performance would likely be comparable to a 350 Rigby mag, but its field penetration length would likely be superior.
Based on this “reality check” using cartridge-bullet combinations with proven field performance, the hunter concluded the 300 Win-180 SAF would likely have been sufficient had he not been able to handload and reproduce the ballistics of a 300 Win-200 WWC or a 358 Win-250 SPH. He reaffirmed his initial conclusion about the 300 Win-200 WWC and 358 Win-250 SPH, now convinced both would likely produce more field wound volume and a shorter travel distance after the kill shot than a 300 Win-180 SAF, and their likely field penetration would be “more than enough” based on the animals to be hunted.
In the previous example, there are two fundamentally important field-performance evaluation concepts that merit emphasis. The first is testing in 20% synthetic gel at the same distance allows any Guppy-metric value of any cartridge-bullet combination to be comparatively evaluated regardless of the chambering and bullet characteristics. This ability allows the V(ST) test value of the 358 Win-250 SPH, a non-magnum chambering firing a cup-and-core bullet weighing 250 grains, to be directly compared to the V(ST) test value of the 300 Win-200 WWC, a magnum chambering firing a bond-lead core bullet weighing 200 grains.
The second concept is Guppy-metric values of a cartridge-bullet combination that is a ballistic twin of one known for its field-performance excellence can be used as performance standards to comparatively evaluate test values of any cartridge-bullet combination, regardless of generic design and impact velocity, as long as testing is done in 20 % synthetic gel at the same distance. As presented in this article’s example, the ballistic-twin link between the 358 Win-225 SGK and the 350 Rigby mag-225 cup-and-core spitzer allowed a realistic appraisal of the 300 Win-180 SAF’s likely field performance based on its V(ST), L(T), and I(V) values.
These comparative-evaluation concepts allow real-world performance reality checks and appraisals of a tested cartridge-bullet combination, such as in the 300 Win-180 SAF example. Based on Table 1’s data, the practical application of that statement is all cartridge-bullet combinations tested except the 358 Win-225 BST and 308 Win-165 BTSX would likely produce field wound volumes greater than a 350 Rigby mag-225 cup-and-core spitzer, and all but the 300 Win-220 SPH would likely produce field-penetration lengths that were greater.
Comparatively evaluating gel-test metric values using the “performance standard” concepts just discussed can be applied by individual hunters to evaluate alternative expanding hunting bullets for their preferred hunting rifle. Testing in 20% synthetic gel can be performed at a distance representative of a typical hunt shot distance. The bullet typically used can be designated as the performance standard, and its V(ST), L(T), and I(V) test values used as the standards for comparison with values of potential alternative bullets. Comparatively evaluating V(ST), L(T), and I(V) test values will identify if any alternate bullet potentially offers better field performance in wounding, penetration, or meat preservation, respectively. Such testing will also identify any bullet performance deficiencies, such as the box-stock 225 Barnes TSX failing to properly expand at a likely hunt impact velocity.
The data on Table 1 underscore that field terminal performance depends on the combined contribution from both the cartridge and the bullet. The cartridge must provide impact velocities compatible with the bullet’s generic design at expected hunt shot distances, as indicated by articles found here and here. When that compatibility does not occur, such as with the 358 Win and the stock 225 Barnes TSX, the result could potentially be an unrecovered animal because the bullet did not properly perform at an impact velocity produced at a reasonably expected hunting distance. When that compatibility does occur, the result could be an “over-achiever” cartridge-bullet combination, such as the 358 Win-250 SPH. Its test results illustrate the generic design and impact velocity synergy that allows a “brush gun” like the 358 Win to run with (and even outrun) the “Big-Dawg” magnums like the 300 Win and 375 H&H.
For example, the 358 Win-250 SPH has a V(ST) test value about 34% more than the iconic African plains game combination of a 300 Win-180 Swift A-Frame (SAF), as well as an L(T) test value that is about 16% more.
Furthermore, the 358 Win-250 SPH has a V(ST) test value only about 11% less than the iconic African all-round combination of a 375 H&H with a 300-grain cup-and-core bullet, but has an L(T) test value that is about 33% more.
The 358 Win-250 SHC is the ballistic twin of a traditionally loaded 35 Whelen launching a 250-grain cup-and-core bullet. In that context, its gel-test results are not surprising because they validate/corroborate over a century of the 35 Whelen’s demonstrated field-performance excellence. Comparison of its Guppy-metric test values with those of other cartridge-bullet combinations with known field performance simply provides a test-based, quantitative way to quickly arrive at the same judgement of field-performance excellence that required over a century of hunter testimonials.
Guppy-metric values obtained from hunt-specific testing in 20% synthetic gel allow such field terminal performance evaluations to be made prior to the hunt. Regardless of whether a single chambering or multiple chamberings are evaluated, such testing allows a strategic selection of a cartridge-bullet combination that is the most responsive to both the hunt circumstances and a hunter’s field terminal performance objectives.